• Follow us

Media Sosial

Why reCAPTCHA is actually an act of human torture

Like many things that start out as a mere annoyance, though eventually grow into somewhat of an affliction. One particular dark and insidious thing has more than reared its ugly head in recent years, and now far more accurately described as an epidemic disease.

I’m talking about the filth that is reCAPTCHA. Yes that seemingly harmless question of “Are you a human?” Truly I wish all this called for were sarcastic puns of ‘The Matrix’ variety but the matter is far more serious.

Google describes reCAPTCHA as:

[reCAPTCHA] is a free security service that protects your websites from spam and abuse.

However, this couldn’t be further from the truth, as reCAPTCHA is actually something that causes abuse. In fact, I would go so far as to say that being subjected to constant reCAPTCHAs is actually an act of human torture and disregard for a person’s human right of mental comfort.

Back in the 90s a bunch of smart-asses realized money was to be made and much time saved by programming bots to do everything for them online. Some bots were good and helpful and made things easier and more efficient for everyone. Whilst others were used to send spam and even caused some websites to crash or suffer lag due to repeated use.

For a time websites employed easily defeated methods for trying to prevent such abuse by making anyone (or anything) who visited/accessed page ‘x’ do ‘y’ thing. Mostly these preventative methods were something stupidly easy for even a computer/bot to solve and did little to stop spam and misuse except prevent access from those only computers/bots that didn’t have a method of solving such simple problems.

To solve what was (at the time) an epidemic in and of itself of bots, reCRAPCHA was born.

Late edit: *Although the topic of ‘who made reCAPTCHA?’ is mostly irrelevant as far as this post’s topic is concerned. I was firmly, albeit still mostly ‘kindly’ reminded that Mr. Luis von Ahn is the inventor of reCAPTCHA and who sold it to Google after ~2 years.* In my defense, the above wording is still right but as an author you have my apologies for not dropping your name sooner Mr. Ahn.

Google came to the rescue of all, as was arguably their responsibility because they were the ones taking it up the rear the hardest from such bots. With the torch now passed to Google, and in really no better shape than the original countermeasure. The below example is what you were tasked with solving, which in hindsight seems fair enough, though in reality – it’s incredulous to ask.


Clearly something like this frustrated people and it wasn’t outsmarting computers either so it was time for Google to get “smart” and being Google, of course they realized they could kill two birds with one stone. So they came up with a way that almost no one was able to criticize them. They turned to making people solve reCAPTCHAs that were actually helping transcribe written works into digital format, searchable by OCR (Optical Character Recognition).

What am I talking about? Well do you remember the days when a reCAPTCHA suddenly went from looking like gobbledegook, to looking like this:


I know I do. I solved thousands of these myself. A simple quick single or double word combination which could also be played out via audio. Mildly annoying but quick and simple for humans, and apparently hard for computers. Except when it became trivial for computers. So Google had to up the ante.

It started out as the lesser of two evils, the good guy vs the bad guys. Except now the fight has evolved into a level of complete disregard for humanity thanks to the likes of these barstads. Yep that’s exactly what it looks like. A “Professional” company that literally EMPLOYS PEOPLE TO SOLVE OTHER PEOPLE’S reCAPTCHAs.

Oh wait it can’t be that ba-

cough cough cough cOuGh and the list goes on, and on, and on…

How to meet the resistance in battle? Well, fast-forward to now and you’ve got this disease that is reCAPTCHA v2. The piece of crap that you now find front-and-fucking-center of every single login/register page or text/form submission on the web. That beast that ‘blocks your path’ every time you want or need to login or write anything online.


In 2017 and 2018, the average time to solve one of these annoyances was a mere 8 seconds for most people. I personally could do them in about 2-3 if I’d had my coffee. In fact, people are doing studies on how long it takes different types of people to solve them. Such as this one here. Though mind you, it’s from back in 2015 where you could solve these in seconds with both hands tied behind your back.

But now?



But don’t for one second think it has anything to do with some increasing level of complexity in the war against bots. No, no, no. How long it takes to now solve these things has increased due to completely deliberate and specific choices that Google has made in reCAPTCHA v3! Yes, I do mean v3 here because these changes (increased complexity in v2) were only made after the arrival of v3.

I’m talking about why, despite you being a completely normal human being of sound deductive capability. You… just… keep… FAILING these things!

So why… why does this happen? It isn’t because you are in fact a dunce who cannot count up to three or cannot tell how many buses or traffic lights there are in a few blurry photos and it also isn’t because you don’t know what a fire hydrant looks like. The reason that people fail reCAPTCHA v3 prompts so consistently now is because Google realized there was no punishment to forcing people to solve more of these ‘human verification puzzles’ and only more to gain by forcing (yes it IS forcing) people to train their AI for free.

“People whine non-stop about hidden crypto-miners in websites but those are in fact a far more honest take of the kind of beast reCAPTCHA is.”

In short. GREED is the reason why you are doomed to fail at least 2 to 3 times every time one of these blocks your path. In fairer times it used to be that if you had recently finished one, Google could tell and you would be able to outright skip any additional annoying puzzle or prompt after you had recently finished one already.

It used to be that Google recorded a bit of your mouse movements and any other inputs you made and if those were ‘human enough’ you were spared the expense and agony of having to dance like a monkey to a tune. But no more. There are no short-cuts now. No free passes. It doesn’t matter if you’re logged into your Google account and allowing all manner of cookies.

Google, despite its ability to track you even through every single reCAPTCHA prompt. They STILL force you to solve these things even though they know damn well you’re not a robot. Why? Because fuck you, that’s why!

“We have now hit such a dystopian phase in internet history that some people are in the business of hiring humans to sit in front of a screen and just solve other people’s reCAPTCHA prompts.”

Things are only set to get worse too, and [I’m certainly to the only one who thinks so. When we hit reCAPTCHA v4 and beyond the time that it takes to solve these prompts will arguably get longer and the tasks become more frustrating.

You will likely be asked to turn on your webcam to confirm you are a human, and not in fact a pesky cat that just stepped onto the keyboard. You will likely be asked to enable access to your microphone and forced to sing the chorus to the likes of Billy Ray Cyrus’ – Achy Breaky Heart. You will likely be asked to open your phone/iPad/whatever and perform some action on a device other than the one you are trying to solve the reCAPTCHA on –

all begging the question of “I mean do you really I mean really need to login or submit that post? What if you try later… Maybe it will just go away? If only.


YOU WILL WANT TO PAY A COMPANY TO SOLVE THESE THINGS FOR YOU. BUT YOU WON’T BE ABLE TO AFFORD IT! Solving reCAPTCHAs will be just another LUXURY like fast download and upload speeds, 4K displays and toilet paper that doesn’t give you a rash.

But hold up, if you don’t think that before you start to even consider that there must be a way to bypass or block these things just like you can block an advertisement online. Leading you to find one of those aforementioned ‘solving services’ and actually ever sign up to one of them.

That there will, and, not LONG, before you ever could get to that stage, be an option to PAY GOOGLE THEMSELVES some form of subscription to bypass these things altogether. If such a thing sounds like a fairytale to you, my dear reader, you are very naïve. I call it the reCAPTCHA Pass I dare say it’s already in the works and that, if you value your time, you will want one. With Google controlling the supply, demand and complexity of these bloody things, you can bet that their prices will be the cheapest!

Really I’m surprised there isn’t a freaking crypto ‘credit’ service that exists that you can use to pay your way out of having to do them. Now wait, that’s an idea! BRB whilst I go patent that.

Mark. My. Words. It will only get worse and there will be multiple businesses and services available pining for your money. ‘When computers attack’ the only thing that can solve the question of “Are you a human?” is literally exactly that, a human. Either you, or some poor sod you are paying. So what’s it gonna be?


This article was originally published by Nils Gronkjaer. You can read it here. 

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

TechCrunch » Social

Patreon sells product curation site Kit to Geniuslink 2019-09-12 12:50:59Patreon, the platform for independent content creators to operate membership businesses for their core fans, announced it is selling the assets of Kit

Google Photos adds a time-traveling version of Stories, 2019-09-12 11:59:18Google Photos is getting its own version of Stories. But instead of focusing on what you’re doing now, as Stories on other platforms like Instag

Hatebase catalogues the world’s hate speech in real 2019-09-10 17:49:26Policing hate speech is something nearly every online communication platform struggles with. Because to police it, you must detect it; and to detect i

Nextdoor adds new funding, closes growth round at 2019-09-10 11:59:39Social networking platform for neighbors Nextdoor today announced it has secured additional funding to close out its $170 million growth round. The ne

Twenty and Mappen merge to help users hang 2019-09-10 10:27:25Today, social networks Twenty and Mappen are joining together in a merger under the Twenty brand. From the beginning, Twenty’s goal has been to

Facebook tightens policies around self-harm and suicide 2019-09-10 09:47:03Timed with World Suicide Prevention Day, Facebook is tightening its policies around some difficult topics, including self-harm, suicide and eating dis

Spotify users can now share music and podcasts 2019-09-09 09:46:22Spotify users can now share their favorite music and podcasts with friends on Snapchat, the company announced this morning, with added support for sha

Freeda raises another $16 million for its media 2019-09-09 03:11:32Italian startup Freeda Media has raised a $16 million Series B round. Existing investor Alven is leading the round, with Endeavor Catalyst, UniCredit

Looking to become the video-based social network of 2019-09-06 12:49:23When Medal.tv first launched on the scene, the company was an upstart trying to be the social network for the gaming generation. Since its debut in Fe

NY attorney general will lead antitrust investigation into 2019-09-06 10:20:50New York Attorney General Letitia James announced this morning that she’s leading an investigation into Facebook over antitrust issues — i

Daily Crunch: Facebook Dating comes to the US 2019-09-05 14:32:14The Daily Crunch is TechCrunch’s roundup of our biggest and most important stories. If you’d like to get this delivered to your inbox ever

Facebook’s lead EU regulator is asking questions about 2019-09-05 13:15:35Facebook’s lead data protection regulator in Europe has confirmed it’s put questions to the company about a major security breach that we


Sony Bravia 4K TVs on sale: Save up 2019-09-14 14:13:08TL;DR: The award-winning Sony Bravia AG9 4K OLED TV is on sale in the PCMag Shop for as low as $2,399 — saving you $302 off the 55-inch or

The Vision Mercedes Simplex is a stunning blend 2019-09-14 14:10:25Mercedes-Benz's newest concept car is shocking, to say the least. This is the Vision Mercedes Simplex, a new concept car from the German manufacturer

Gorgeous Wolverine Glacier photos from the front lines 2019-09-14 12:36:43Enjoy these views of Alaska's Wolverine Glacier while you can. Soon enough, they'll be relegated to a distant memory. As Earth's climate shifts und

Thieves on the run after stealing solid gold 2019-09-14 12:17:32If you're going to do an art heist, perhaps you shouldn't select a target that's as cumbersome and obvious as a solid gold toilet. A golden toilet

Stark new Saturn images give a detailed look 2019-09-14 10:38:32NASA released its annual images of the planet Saturn taken by the Hubble Space Telescope Thursday, giving the citizens of earth an update on what's b

Netflix's 'Tall Girl' needs way more of Anjelika 2019-09-14 09:00:00When Netflix released a trailer for its new original film Tall Girl at the end of August, Twitter had a field day (as it's wont to do). Users across

15 single line tattoos that are simply beautiful 2019-09-14 08:00:00There are endless possibilities to consider when contemplating your next ink. But in the vast sea of roses and sailor tats, finding something truly or

iPhone 11, Dyson V8, bObsweep robot vacuum, Samsung 2019-09-14 05:08:51Has your smartphone seen better days? If so, we think it's time for you to upgrade. Pre-orders for the new Apple iPhone 11 has already begun and Veri

Master Tableau, the platform that takes boring raw 2019-09-14 05:00:00TL;DR: The informative Mastering Tableau Certification Bundle is on sale for $25, down from $770. Forget about deep dives and synergy, data is the buz

There's a big sale on these hard luggage 2019-09-14 05:00:00TL;DR: Easy-to-transport Tach Tuff Connectable Hard Luggage Sets are on sale, starting at $274.99. Imagine this: You’re heading out on a huge so

Tech gadgets on sale: Shop Chromebooks, Mac Minis, 2019-09-14 05:00:00We're saying goodbye to summer and ushering in fall, and we could all use a pick-me-up (and something more than a pumpkin spice latte, thank you). Th

How to talk to the men in your 2019-09-14 03:53:20Toxic masculinity is a term with a toxic legacy.  As with many words typically associated with feminist discourse, 'toxic masculinity' is a phr

The Next Web

MoviePass is effectively dead and will shut down 2019-09-13 19:22:59If you’re still a Movie Pass subscriber for some reason, it appears tonight is your last chance to use the service. In an “I hope no one n

How WSDG and Gimlet built world-class podcast recording 2019-09-13 18:32:32Picture a professional recording studio. What do you see? Perhaps a band rocking out in an acoustically treated room, or a vocalist singing softly int

Free software icon Richard Stallman has some moronic 2019-09-13 17:22:54The world of academia is in turmoil over the shock discovery that disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein funded several several prestigious science and t

UK committee condemns loot boxes (‘surprise mechanics’) as 2019-09-13 15:46:56The UK Parliament’s Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee today released their conclusions from their investigation into addictive ga

Twitter’s refusal to dox a cow stymies Republican’s 2019-09-13 14:31:25US Rep. Devin Nunes can’t seem to catch a break. First, despite his memo blaming Obama and the FBI for all the evils in the world, his fellow fo

The GoCycle GXi is a futuristic, premium e-bike 2019-09-13 14:00:55E-bikes are changing the way we get around cities, but they are usually bulky, heavy affairs that are even less friendly to trains and cabs than a reg

All we know about the ambitious OnePlus smart 2019-09-13 08:27:46Last September, OnePlus told us it’s planning to launch a smart TV in 2019. According to the company’s announcement in August, it’ll

Learn how to launch your consulting business in 2019-09-13 08:00:00By starting your own consultancy business, you can not only help others improve, but create a healthy income stream around your schedule and your life

Scammers are now selling stolen cash for Bitcoin 2019-09-13 07:58:24Just when you probably thought you’d seen it all, scammers are now selling discounted hacked cash in exchange for Bitcoin on the dark web. Accor

It’s possible to monetize data while respecting consumer 2019-09-13 07:51:32Murky policies, tricky wordings, and sneaky assumptions about consent… these are just a few of the shifty tactics being used by companies to le

11 Ways Novices Can Start the Process of 2019-09-13 05:00:41Beginners may find it challenging figuring out what they need to know in order to get started with artificial intelligence programming. Here are some

Apple’s revised policy for kids’ apps allows devs 2019-09-13 04:05:50Apple has revised its App Store Review Guidelines with regards to kids’ apps, and its upcoming Sign in with Apple authentication featu

E-Commerce Times

Is Your E-Commerce Platform Ready for the Next 2019-09-12 13:35:40Disruption drives business failure and success. Most people think technology drives disruption, but technology merely enables disruption -- changing c

Zoho Is Starting to Look Like a Utility 2019-09-12 08:00:22It has been my belief for several years that our industry is trending toward the formation of an information utility. I draw this conclusion carefully

California Applies Brakes to Galloping Gig Economy 2019-09-12 06:23:09California Assembly Bill 5, which would require many businesses to hire workers as employees rather than independent contractors -- and reclassify the

50 AGs Gun for Google in Antitrust Offensive 2019-09-11 13:55:13The attorneys general of 48 states, plus those from United States territory Puerto Rico and Washington, D.C., have joined in an investigation into whe

New Insightly Marketing Platform Modernizes Legacy CRM 2019-09-10 14:19:25Insightly has announced the availability of Insightly Marketing, which integrates marketing, sales and project management into a single platform to su

Shifting Cable-TV Landscape Demands New Strategies for Survival 2019-09-10 13:26:10X1 is a Comcast-branded pay-TV service that gives users more control over their television experience. The service recently gained new features that c

Rethinking the User Interface for Consumer Voice Tech 2019-09-09 08:00:00Voice can provide a simple, compelling user experience, but the path to adding voice controls to any product, service or application is complex. As do

Big Data's Seismic Effect on the Broadcasting Industry 2019-09-05 12:13:49Digital transformation has left hardly any industry unshaken. In broadcasting, it's safe to say that it has transformed completely the way we create,

Samsung May Have New Foldable Phone in Wings 2019-09-04 13:33:01Samsung's first-generation foldable phone isn't expected until later this month, but reports of a second-generation device to be released in early 2

How to Choose Shipping Software to Scale Your 2019-09-03 12:09:28Implementing shipping software can be a big step in scaling your e-commerce business -- providing a way to create shipping labels quickly, to gain acc

The High Stakes of Oracle's Appeal 2019-08-31 08:00:00Now Oracle is appealing the Pentagon's award to Amazon of its $10 billion JEDI contract to provide cloud computing solutions. "The Court of Federal

Can Cable TV Survive the 5G Wireless Threat? 2019-08-30 13:07:22Traditional cable TV providers will face a big competitive threat in the next decade from the Internet, IPTV and 5G wireless. Cable TV typically lands


How CBD Helped Paul Pierce Cope With PTSD 2019-09-13 17:34:00The NBA legend talks about his stabbing in 2000, his road to recovery, and his new line The Truth CBD Remedies.

To Really Innovate, Think Like a User 2019-09-13 16:30:00Here are some strategies to help broaden your perspective and ensure success.

8 Examples of Brilliant Instagram Marketing 2019-09-13 16:00:00These high-profile accounts demonstrate how to capitalize on your target audience.

Simple Ways to Calm Down During Times of 2019-09-13 15:09:00You can't out-hustle stress and anxiety. Try these techniques to calm yourself down and find inner happiness.

5 Proven Strategies for Scaling Your Cannabis Startup 2019-09-13 14:20:00How to grow from a small, fledgling business to a profitable one.

4 Ways to Turn Cold LinkedIn Connections Into 2019-09-13 14:00:00Try these tactics to turn LinkedIn into a client generator.

13 Superstitions of Super Successful People 2019-09-13 12:30:00Check out these rituals from the book 'Recipes for Good Luck.'

Want to Increase Your Brain Power, Decrease Your 2019-09-13 12:00:00Hobbies improve your life and support your mission of building an empire.

7 Gourmet Prison-Food Recipes for Bootstrapped Entrepreneurs 2019-09-13 10:45:00A former inmate's guide to surviving those early, hungry days of small-business ownership.

How Do Millionaires Spend Their Money? 2019-09-13 10:30:00Not all of the wealthy spend like they're wealthy.

20 Ways to Boost Your Energy at Work 2019-09-13 09:40:00This infographic will teach you simple tricks to help keep you going all day long.

Learn How to Create a Marketing Plan That 2019-09-13 09:30:00This one-hour course will show you how to convert prospects into lifetime customers.

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.